Institute of General Physiology,
University of Siena,
53100 Siena,
Italy
There are several reasons explaining why autohaemotherapy
after
ozone treatment has remained in a scientific limbo: firstly,
the
biological basis have remained nebulous and have been
barely
studied [1,2], partly because of lack of financial support
by the
pharmaceutical industry, secondly the therapeutic schemes
have
been elaborated on personal bias rather than on the evaluation
of
objective parameters [3,4], thirdly clinical experience,
although
vast, had remained limited to private practice with the
consequence that results have been reported on a anecdotal
fashion
and never published in peer-reviewed journals [1,3-8];
even worse,
a few quacks have completely discredited ozonetherapy
by claiming
wonderful results and exploiting patients. Fourthly,
ozone has
often been used unproperly without knowing exactly its
physicochemical properties [9] and fifthly, the awareness
that
ozone is one of tile worst pollutant and can generate
formation of
oxidizing compounds [10-14] has comprehensibly originated
a strong
prejudice for its use. Thus, it is not surprising that
the use of
ozone for medical purposes is only allowed in Germany,
Austria,
Switzerland, Italy, Russia, Cuba and in a few States
of USA.
England and France, although widely using ozone for the
treatment
of drinking water, refrain from using it in Medicine.
This
involutive state of affairs has now undergone a critical
reappraisal by considering that:
a) of the various routes of ozone administration,
the exposure
of a
volume of blood to a precise
ozone dose offers and meaningful
and
reproducible delivery system.
b) Ozone is now considered a citokine inducer
with a definite
benefit/risk ratio. As a consequence,
autohaemotherapy may
favour
immunorestoration in secondary
cellular immune deficiencies.
c) Blood cellular components display such
a marked functional
heterogeneity that under ozone
action quite different
biological
responses have to be expected.
This does not exclude however,
that therapeutic activity in
each disease has a
multifactorial
origin.
Routes of ozone administration in different pathological
conditions.
The solubility of ozone in water, is about 50% higher
than oxygen
and it follows Henry's law [1,15]. However when ozone
dissolves in
the plasma, Henry's law is no longer valid because ozone
decomposes in about one second and generates a cascade
of unstable
and highly reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI) among
which are
aldehydes, ozonides, hydrogen peroxide and lipid hydroperoxides
that almost instantaneously react with membranous and
cytoplasmic
components [1,14-17]. On the other hand, cells and body
fluids
contain a wealth of antioxidant compounds such as vitamins,
low
molecular weight compounds and proteins [18] as well
as a number
of enzymes able to either scavenge ROI or to rapidly
regenerate
reducing compounds. Both parenteral (intravenous, intra-arterial,
intramuscular, subcutaneous and intra-articular) and
local (nasal,
tubal, oral, vaginal, vesical, colorectal and cutaneous)
routes
have been used [1,3] for the treatment of a number of
pathological
states with ozone (Table 1 [19-26]). One is surprised
to note
that, with the exception of the intravenous route, only
minor
side-effects have been observed probably because the
potential
toxicity of ozone is largely quenched by the body antioxidant
reservoir and because the initial irritating (burning
feeling)
action of ozone in tissues is within few minutes followed
by
analgesia.
Use of the intravenous administration route is extremely
dangerous
because even if the gaseous mixture of oxygen-ozone is
administered very slowly with a pump, it frequently procures
lung
embolization and serious side effects, particularly when
daily
dosing is up to 120 ml. Moreover, to the best of my knowledge,
this procedure does not yield clinical benefit and no
data have
been published.
Jacobs [27] has analysed the type of accidents and side-effects
after ozonetherapy in Germany in a total of 5,579,238
applications
performed in 384,775 patients up to 1982. Although the
percentage
of accident due to ozone was 0.0007 %, it nonetheless
included
four fatalities most likely due to lung embolization
while the
remaining were minor accidents due to technical mistakes.
During
the last decade the administration of ozone via the intravenous
route has been prohibited in Europe but regrettably someone
still
uses it in USA.
Intraarterial administration of 02-03, useful for treating
chronic
limb ischemia, is far less risky probably because only
a small
volume of gas is injected and because there is rapid
gas
solubilization and absorption at the capillary level
[3,4,6,8].
Administration of up to 150 ml of 02-03, via intramuscular
and
subcutaneous routes is painful for a few minutes, and
although
therapeutic efficacy is claimed to be good, convincing
clinical
data are lacking [3]. My prejudice against these routes,
particularly when used for immunomodulatory purposes,
is that
ozone dosing is totally empirical because no stoichiometric
relationship can be defined between the ozone dose and
the unknown
volume of blood exposed in an internal cavity or tissue.
Of the local treatments, the cutaneous one (for torpid
ulcers or
necrotic lesions due to vascular limb disorders), is
free of side
effects and effective particularly when combined to
autohaemotherapy [3,6,8,15].
Colorectal insufflation over a period of one minute of
up to 800
ml of 02-03 (ozone concentration 20 ug/ml) is reported
to be free
of side-effects and effective in AIDS patients with intractable
diarrhoea and in hepatitis patients [28-30]. This route
ought to
be borne in mind because the procedure of execution is
simple, it
can be done by the patient at home and it is a practical
alternative when there is not a venous access. However,
so far
neither endpoints are available for establishing an optimal
dosage
for this route, nor do we know how ozone insufflated
into the
colon lumen works. While there will occur an improved
oxygenation
of portal and peripheral blood [29] and possibly of intestinal
lymph, we can only speculate on the activation of the
colon-
associated lymphoid system. It remains also unknown whether
the
bactericidal activity of ozone enhances absorption of
bacterial
compounds, similar to muramyl/ peptides, with immunoenhancing
properties.
In conclusion, all of these routes have the disadvantage
that
ozone dosing has to be defined on a trial and error basis
which is
difficult and time-consuming to assess. Thus, at present
time,
ozonated autohaemotherapy, first described by Wehrli
and Steinbart
[31], represents the best option because it implies an
almost
stoichiometric relationship between a known dose of ozone
versus a
volume of blood measured by weight (about 105 g correspond
to 100
ml) and because we can correlate several biochemical
and
immunological parameters with ozone dosing. These are
crucial
advantages that associated with the simplicity of the
procedure,
portray ozonated autohaemotherapy as a very important
therapeutic
possibility. After the discovery [32] that endothelial
and other
cells synthesize NO, that is an inorganic free radical
gas and use
it as a mediator and immune modulator, we ought to examine
without
any bias the biological activity of ozone.
Induction of cytokines from blood mononuclear cells (BMC)
during
ozonation.
Autohaemotherapy represents an almost ideal model because
there is
a reasonable stoichiometric relationship between ozone
and blood.
However, even in this case, among blood samples there
are
unavoidable uncertainties such as a variable amount of
antioxidant
compounds [18,33], of intracellular reducing enzymes
[33,34], as
well as quantitative and qualitative differences in cell
components. As we have found [35,36] already great variability
among normal donors, we expect an even greater variability
among
patients and for this reason, rather than suggesting
an optimal
ozone concentration (around 70 ug/ml ozone per ml of
blood at
normal barometric pressure), we propose that effective
ozone
concentrations range between 50 and 80 ug/ml without
any evident
toxicity when erythrocyte counts range between 3.5-5.0
x
10(6)/mm(3). Within these concentrations there is no
formation of
metahaemoglobin, either haemolysis or intraerythrocylic
reduced
glutathione levels remain below 3.0 or 10%, respectively
[35,36],
cell viability is normal and no morphologic cell damage
is evident
by electron microscopic analysis (Bocci et al., manuscript
in
preparation).
The new result which has confirmed the hypothesis that
ozone can
act as a cytokine's inducer [37] is that blood, after
being
exposed for a few minutes to concentrations of ozone
ranging from
10 up to 90 ug/ml (per ml of blood) at normal barometric
pressure,
upon the usual incubation in air/CO, (95/5%) for up to
72 hours,
progressively releases small amounts of cytokines such
as
interferon (IFN) B and y, tumor necrosis factor (TNFx),
interleukins (IL) 1B, 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10, granulocyte-macrophage,
colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) and activated transforming
growth factor (TGF) B1 [35,36,38-40]. IFNx has been barely
detectable and other cytokines will be measured as soon
as we have
suitable reagents. At least for IFNs B/y and TNFx there
is
correspondence between biological and immunoenzymatic
activities.
In spite of great variability among normal blood samples,
that is
a normal fact due to the existence of either low or high
responders [41], there is an ozone dose/cytokine response
effect
that tends to level off when ozone concentration reaches
the 70
ug/ml mark. At the 105 ug/ml level, that is the maximum
ozone
concentration delivered by the generator, we have often
noted a
depressed cytokine production suggesting a possible cytotoxic
effect [40]. Cytokine production is markedly depressed
when blood
is collected in the usual Ca++ chelating solution (citrate-
phosphate-dextrose) and incubated in the absence of extracellular
Ca.++ This finding led us to test the physiological
anticoagulant, i.e., heparin (25 U/ml of blood) additioned
with
CaCl2, to a final concentration of 5mM [35]. Thus, a
five-fold
surplus of extracellular Ca++ (physiological Ca++ level
is about 1
mM) displays a superinducing effect [2] but it must be
noted that
further Ca++ addition up to 50 mM, although modestly
increasing
cytokine's production, yields a prohibitive haemolysis
[35].
However, heparin occasionally presents the problem of
excessive
anticoagulation as it has recently occurred in two hepatitis
patients leading us to re-evaluate whether CPD treated
blood, once
heparinized and recalcified at physiological levels,
is
sufficiently activated. Data to be reported soon
have shown that,
after Ca++ addition, the production of cytokine is partially
restored whereas blood sample incubated without Ca++
are
consistently inhibited. These results have practical
importance
because they indicate that either CPD- or heparin-treated
blood
after ozonation and reinfusion will release similar amounts
of
cytokines in vivo. As a rule now, for patients
under
anticoagulant therapy, or aspirin, or prone to the haemorrhagic
syndrome, or thrombocytopenia or hepatic dysfunction,
we collect
blood in CPD only thus avoiding any risk of dyscoagulation.
How ozone acts at the cellular level remains uncertain
and for the
time being, it is a matter of speculation. Probably
ozone may
oxidize unspecifically some carbohydrates, probably galactose
[42,43], present on the cell membrane lectins leading
to a
coupling with transducer proteins and to an enhanced
Ca++ influx.
Moreover ROI can passively diffuse through the cell membrane
and
activate the gene-regulatory Nuclear Factor-Kappa B (NF-Kappa
B)
that appears to play many roles in the immune cells and
certainly
causes gene activation for several cytokines [44,45].
At the
present our working hypothesis is that ozone acts unspecifically:
the bulk of generated ROI is consumed by antioxidant
substances in
plasma and by the huge amounts of phospholipids present
in
erythrocytes because their membranous surface is as large
as 70
m(2) per 100 ml of blood. As there is about 1 BMC
every 3000
erythrocytes, there should occur a transient overproduction
of
ROI, for them to reach the trans-activating factor in
the
cytoplams and release the inhibitory subunit I Kappa
B. Schreck
et al [44] have indicated a threshold of about 30 uM
of hydrogen
peroxide to be effective in their system, implying that
if ROI are
not homogenously distributed, BMC will not be activated.
We do
not envisage and actually we do not notice cell damage
because
intracellular catalase, superoxide dismutase as well
as other
reducing enzymes and chainbraking compounds [14,17,18,33],
are
capable of quickly neutralizing or scavenging residual
ROI
terminating the ozone action. In conclusion it
would seem that
ozone dosing is critical in the sense that if it is too
low it is
probably ineffective while if it is excessive, it may
induce
oxidative stress and eventually cell apoptosis [46].
Another interesting characteristic of this approach is
that blood,
after being thouroughly exposed to O2/O3 ex vivo for
5 minutes can
be reinfused in the donor without practically any trace
of ozone.
Only the pO2 level, from a baseline value of 33-40 mmHg
reaches in
a few minutes a plateau level of about 400 presumably
returning to
the original value after gas exchange in the capillaries.
Lipid
hydroperoxide levels in plasma increase about 3-fold
immediately
after ozonation and return to baseline values within
3-4 hours
when blood is incubated in vitro. However it is most
important to
note that in vivo, even 5 min after reinfusion, peroxides
in the
plasma remain at baseline value.
Both CPD- and heparin-treated blood are occasionally mixed
to
minimize erythrocyte sedimentation and reinfused fairly
rapidly
without any vascular or respiratory distress. In order
to
stabilize the plasma levels of antioxidants and to make
sure that
patients receive a normal vitaminic support we have always
described a daily multivitamin (including vitamin C and
E)
supplement.
Mechanisms of action of ozonated autohaemotherapy.
Until recently it was thought that in chronic viral diseases,
the
virucidal properties of ozone were of paramount importance
[1,3,7,21,47-49] for the therapeutic effect, neglecting
the fact
that the viral reservoirs are the internal organs (liver
for
hepatitis, lymph nodes and spleen for HIV infection,
neuronal
ganglia for herpes viruses etc) and that less viral particles
are
free in the plasma, implying a minimal direct effect
during
exposure of a small aliquot of plasma to ozone [50].
Moreover it
was reported that after ozonation, leukocytes improved
their
phagocytic activity and that immunoglobulin levels could
increase
without underlying the causes of these biological effects
[51].
The breakthrough has come with the demonstration that
ozone acts
as an inducer of cytokine's production [35,36,38-40].
Since then
the approach of ozonized autohaemotherapy has gained
a rational
basis and one can understand why synthesis of antibodies
can be
stimulated by IL-6. enhanced phagocytic functions and
leukocytosis
can be due to IL-8 and GM-CSF and how both direct and
indirect
antiviral activities can be stimulated by IFNB, y and
TNFx. In
viral diseases, however, it cannot be excluded that small
amounts
of free virus inactivated in the plasma during ozonization
may act
either as an endogenous immunogen or/and an activator
of cell-
mediated immunity. It is worth while mentioning that
autohaemotherapy has been surprisingly used also for
the treatment
of autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis [52]
and it
would be desirable to investigate whether particular
ozone
concentrations may enhance the release of inhibitory
cytokines
leading either to the suppression of autoreactive cytotoxic
T cell
clones or/and to the blocking of inflammatory cytokines
by the
release of either soluble receptors or/and cytokine antagonists.
It is possible that the release of IL-lO [53] and TGFB1[54,55]
can
serve the useful purpose of quenching an excessive immune
stimulation, thus leading to an orderly reprogramming
of immune
responses.
Distribution and fate of ozunatcd blood cells after reinfusion.
With the exception of the most aged erythrocytes that,
being more
susceptible to ozone,,re likely to be taken up by the
reticulo-
endothelial system [56],it is reasonable to speculate
that most
erythrocytes will continue to circulate in the vascular
system. On
the other hand, activated BMC may home in various lymphoid
and
non-lymphoid organs and we plan to verify this possibility
with
Indium-III labelled cells as soon as possible. If this
happens, as
we have shown during in vitro incubation [35,36], BMC
will release
around the pericellular environment various cytokines
which can
bind to the appropriate receptors on neighbouring stationary
or in
transit cells. In comparison to classical mitogens, which
can
easily activate 10-20% of the isolated BMC causing the
synthesis
of large amounts of cytokines, depending upon the fairly
critical
ozone dosing, a smaller percentage of BMC appears activated
so
that the minute amount of released cytokines is consumed
in
cellular microenvironments and does not emerge in the
general
circulation via the lymphatic system. This tentative
explanation
is supported by two pieces of evidence: firstly, we have
never
detected any significant change in cytokine's levels
in the plasma
of healthy volunteers at 1, 3, 6, 9 and 24 hours after
reinfusion
of ozonated blood [57]. In contrast, after injection
of as little
as 4 ng/Kg body weight of endotoxin in patients, there
is a
massive release of pyrogenic cytokines with IL-1, IL-6
and TNFx
peaking a few hours after endotoxin administration [58].
The
second point is that although autohaemotherapy does not
allow the
release of endogenous cytokines in the circulation, which
is an
important advantage. it has a real biological effect
because 48-72
hours after reinfusion we have measured [57] in BMC an
increase of
the Mx protein that is one of the best indicators of
IFN release
[59]. The progressive enlargement of the area under curve
of Mx
protein versus time throughout autohaemotherapeutic treatments
suggests that in vivo there occurs a progressive amplification
of
the priming and IFN production [57]. Thus, ozonated
autohaemotherapy may be assimilated to a slightly enhanced
physiological response [41,60] due to a gaseous inducer
which acts
rapidly and disappears. Further support to this interpretation
is
that typical side effects such as chills, fever, fatigue
and
nausea never occur after autohaemotherapy and actually
the
patients often report a sense of well-being and euphoria
that may
be due to improved oxygenation or/and release of hormonal
factors
not yet identified. As far as the number of treatments
to be
carried out is concerned, one treatment only can be hardly
effective as the number of ozonated BMC present in 300
mi of blood
is probably less than 0.1% of the total BMC mass [61].
If this
calculation is correct, only the prolonged repetition
of
autohaemotherapy (two treatments weekly for several months)
can
allow a progressively amplified activation of the immune
system
via numerous pathways such as activation of either major
histocompatibility complex-restricted cytolysis, or unspecific
killing and removal of viral-infected and metastatic
cells. Table
I reports a list of chronic viral diseases or pathological
situations accompanied by either immune deficiency or
immune
dysregulation, where ozonated autohaernotherapy has and
could play
a beneficial role.
Autohaemotherapy may prove to be very useful as an adjuvant
treatment particularly if either chemotherapy or/and
radiotherapy
have been effective in reducing the tumor mass. Several
immunotherapeutic approaches such as: a) therapy with
monospecific
or bispecific antibodies [62]; b) adoptive immunotherapy
with more
or less genetically engineered cells [63]; c) exogenous
administration of either an array of immunostimulants
[64] or/and
d) of recombinant cytokines such as IFNs, IL-1, 2, 3,
6 and 12,
TNFx and leukopoietins are being actively pursued. Approaches
a to
c are in a more or less advanced experimental phase while
therapy
with cytokines has dominated the scene in the last decade.
Unfortunately pharmacological administration of cytokines,
that
physiologically are not present in the circulation, causes
a
substantial increase of their plasma levels which correlate
well
with fairly severe toxicity [65]. Clinical results in
solid
neoplasms have been far below expectations and the cost/benefit
ratio is very high [66].
The variety of biological effects depends upon the heterogeneity
of blood cells.
While immunomodulatory effects are due to BMC activation,
the
beneficial effect of autohaemotherapy in chronic limb
ischemia, in
cardiac, ophthalmologic and cerebral vasculopathies [3,4,6,8,22]
in infections and in burns [1,3,4,6,8,15,19,20] can be
explained
by improved transport of oxygen due either to increased
oxygen
availability, or oxygen delivery to hypoxic tissues due
to an
increase of 2-3 diphosphoglycerate in erythrocytes. The
rapid
healing of torpid ulcers in ischemic disorders is becoming
particularly interesting since the demonstration that
transforming
growth factors (TGF) B1 accelerates the healing process
[67-69]
and that levels of activated TGF B1 increase substantially
after
ozonation of blood, probably due to partial degranulation
of
platelets [40]. There is no doubt that improved oxygenation
enhances cell metabolism and proliferation and that the
local
application of ozone inhibits bacterial infections but,
until now,
the crucial role of proteins such as TGF B1, vascular
endothelial
growth factor (VEGF) for enhancing neovascularization
[70] and
healing has not been taken into account. Thus it appears
that
clinical benefits possibly derive from the activation
of
erythrocyte function, the release of either TGF B1, other
growth
factors and by improved leukocytic functions in terms
of removal
of necrotic tissue and bactericidal activities.
Final remarks
It has been pointed out that ozonated autohaemotherapy
performed
with an optimized procedure represents a powerful therapeutic
approach. Its main advantages are the lack of toxicity,
often a
feeling of well-being and the equilibrated, although
slow,
stimulation of cytokine production accompanied by improved
oxygenation and metabolism. Both in the treatment of
neoplasia,
particularly after chemiotherapy, and of chronic viral
diseases
the frequent report of well-being after treatment is
relevant
because the quality of life of these patients is generally
poor.
We are planning to investigate the reason of euphoria
and we
believe that it may be due to an immune-neuroendocrine
response
elicited by the ozonated blood. On clinical ground there
is also
the need to carry out extensive and well-controlled clinical
trials in several diseases including HIV infection [50].
The
treatment is simple to execute, safe, far less expensive
that
comparable procedures and could be carried out easily
also in
Third-World Countries where it could be applied also
to several
parasitic diseases.
Aknowledgements
I am very grateful to Miss Patrizia Marrocchesi for her
skill and
patience in preparing the manuscript. This work has been
partially
supported by MURST (40%) and by the National Research
Council
(CNR), Rome, Targeted Project "Applicazioni cliniche
della ricerca
oncologica" (ACRO).
REFERENCES
1 Viebahn, R. (1994) The use of ozone in medicine.
Karl F. Haug
Publishers, Heidelberg, pp. 1-178.
2 Bocci, V. (1994) Autohaemotherapy after treahnent
of blood with
ozone. A reappraisal. J. Int Med. Res. 22, 131-144.
3 Mattassi, R. (1985) Ozonoterapia. Org;unizzuzione Editoriale
Medico Scientifica, Milnno, pp. 1-179.
4 Kokitansky, O., Rokitansky, A.. Steiner, I., Trubel,
W.,
Viebahn, R. and Washiittl, J. (1981) Die Ozontherapie
bei
peripheren, arteriellen Durchblutungsstijrungen: Klinik,
biochemische und blutgasanalytische Untersuchungen. In:
Wasser.
Ozon-Weltkongress, Berlin, pp. 53-75.
5 Zabel, W. (1960) Ganzheitsbehandlung der Geschwulsterkrankungen.
Hippokrates 31, 751-760.
6 Werkmeister, 11. (I')G8) Ozon-Sauerstoff- Injektionsbehandlung
Krebskranker unter besonderer Beriicksichtigung gleichzeitiger
Stralllentherapie. Deutscher RGntgenkongress 1968. Georg
Thieme
Verlag, Stuttgart, pp. S33.
7 Konrad, H. (1991) Ozone therapy for viral diseases.
In:
Proceedings IOth Ozone World Congress 19-21 March 1991,
Monaco.
International Ozone Association, Zurich, pp. 75-83.
8 Werkmeister, H. (1991) The efficacy of OJO, low-pressure
application in badly healing wounds. In: Proceedings
IOth Ozone
World Congress 19-21 March 1991, Monaco. International
Ozone
Association, Zurich, pp. 41-53.
9 Garber, G.E., Cameron, D.W., Hawley-Foss, N., Greenway,
D. and
Shannon, M.E. (1991) The use of ozone-treated blood in
the therapy
of HIV infection and immune disease: a pilot study of
safety and
efficacy. AIDS 5, 981-984.
10 Hoigne, J. and Bader, H. (1979) Ozonation of water:
selectivity
and rate of oxidation of solutes. Ozone Sci. & Engin.
1, 73-85.
11 Dziedzic, D. and White, H.J. (1987) Response of T-cell-
deficient mice to ozone exposure. J. Toxicol. Environ.
Health 21,
57-71.
12 Lippman, M. (1989) Health effects of ozone, a critical
review.
J. Am. Air Pollut. Control Assoc, 39,672-695.
13 Editorial, (1991) Ozone: too much in the wrong place.
Lancet
338, 221-222.
14 O'Neill, C.A., van der Vliet, A., Hu, M.-L., Kaur,
H., Cross,
C.E., Louie, S. and Halliwell,
B. (1993) Oxidation of biologic molecules by ozone: the
effect of
pi-I. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 122, 4'37-505.
15 Mian, E.U. and Agostini, G. (1988) Principi di balneoterapia
ozonizzata. Edizioni Dedalus, pp. 1-146.
16 Giamalva, D., Church, D.F. and Pryer, W.A. (1985) A
comparison
of the rates of ozonation of biological antioxidants
and oleate
and linoleate esters. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.
133, 773-779.
17 Cross, C.E., Reznick, A.Z., Packer, L., Davis, P.A.,
Suzuki,
Y.J. and Ilalliwell, 13. (1992) Oxidative damage to human
plasma
proteins by ozone. Free Rad. Res. Comms. 15, 347-352.
18 Halliwell, B. and Gutteridge, J.M.C. (1990) The antioxidants
of
human extracellular fluids. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 280,
1-8.
19 Aubourg, P. (1938) L'Ozone medical: Production, Posologic,
Modes d'application cliniques. Bull. med. Paris 52, 745-749.
20 Wolff. II.1-i. (1975) Uber die "kasseniibliche" Ozontherapie.
Erfahr. hk. 24, 123-128.
21 Dorstewitz, H. (1981) Wasser. 5. Ozon-Weltkongress-
1981.
Colloquium Verlag, Berlin.
22 Riva Sanseverino, E., Meduri. R.A., Pizzino, A., Prantera,
M.
and Martini, E. (1990) Effects of oxygen-ozone therapy
on age-
related degenerative retinal maculopath? . Panminerva
Medica 32,
77-84.
23 Wolff, H.H. (1974) Die Behandlung peripherer
Durchblutungsstgrungen mit Ozon. Erfahr. hk. 23, 181-184.
24 Fisch, E.A. (1953) Metodo all'ozono nella cura del
canale
radicolare infetto e dell'osteite periapicale. Riv. It.
Stomatologia 8, 208-209.
25 Filippi, A. and Kirschner, N. (1994) Der einsatz von
ozoniertem
wasser in der zahnheiikunde. In: Proceedings "Ozone application
in
Medicine, Thursday, September 1, 1994", Zurich, Switzerland.
pp.
8-11.
26 Ranzini, M., Bignamini, A., Micheletti. P., Valdenassi,
L.,
Agostini, G., Richelmi, I'. and Berte, 1;. (1993) Subcutaneous
oxygen-ozone therapy in indurative hypodermatitis and
in localised
lipodystrophies: a clinical study of efficacy and tolerability.
Acta Toxicol. Iher. XIV, 273-288.
27 Jacobs, M.-Th. (1986) Untersuchung uber Zwischenfalle
und
typische Komplikationen in der Ozon-Sauerstoff-Therapie.
Ozonachrichten 5, 1-5.
28 Knoch, H.-G., Koschke, W. and Klug, W. (1987) Die Sauerstoff-
Ozontherapie in der
Proktologie. Aktuelle Koloproktologie Band 4, 13. Edition
Nymphenburg, Miinchen, pp.
161-173.
29 Knoch, H.-G., Klug, W. and Roschke, W. (1987)
13lutgasanalytische Untersuchungen nach rektaler Insufflation
von
ozonisiertem Sauerstoff-?`iercxperimentelle Untersuchungen.
Colo-
proctology 9. 336-340.
30 Carpendale, M.T., Freeberg, i. and McLeod Griffiss,
J. (1993)
Does Ozone alleviate AIDS diarrhea? i. Clin. Gastroenterol.
17.
142-145.
31 Wehrli, I-'. and Steinbart, H. (1954) Erfahrungen mil
der
haematogenen oxydations therapie (HOT). Ars Medici 10,
44-51.
32 Knowles, R.G. and Moncada, S. (1994) Nitric oxide synthases
in
mammals. Biochem. i.
298, 249-258.
33 Meister, A. (1994) Glutathione-ascorbic acid antioxidant
system
in animals. i. Biol. Chem.
269, 9397-9400.
34 Van der Zee, i., Tijssen-Christianse, K., Dubbelman,
T.M.A.R.
and Van Steveninck, J. (1987) The influence of ozone
on human red
blood cells. Comparison with other mechanisms of oxidative
stress.
Biochim. Biophys. Acta 924, 111-118.
35 Bocci, V., Luzii, E., Corradeschi, F., Paulesu, L.
and Di
Stefano, A. (1993) Studies on the biological effects
of ozone: 3.
An attempt to define conditions for optimal induction
of
cytokines. Lymphokine Cytokine Res. 12, 121-126.
36 Bocci, V., Luzzi, E., Corradeschi, F., Paulesu, L.,
Rossi, R.,
Cardaioli, E. and Di Simplicio, P. (1993) Studies on
the
biological effects of ozone: 4. Cytokine production and
glutathione levels in human erythrocytes. i. Biol. Regul.
Homeost.
Agents 7, 133-138.
37 Bocci, V. (1992) Ozonization of blood for the therapy
of viral
diseases and immunodeficiencies. A hypothesis. Med. Hypotheses
39,
30-34.
38 Bocci, V. and Paulesu, L. (1990) Studies on the biological
effects of ozone 1. Induction of interferon gamma on
human
leucocytes. Haematologica 75, 510-515.
39 Paulesu, L., Luzzi, E. and Bocci, V. (1991) Studies
on the
biological effects of ozone: 2. Induction of tumor necrosis
factor
(TNF-a) on human Leucocytes. Lymphokine Cytokine Res.
10, 409-412.
40 Bocci, V., Luzzi, E., Corradeschi, F. and Silvestri,
S. (1994)
Studies on the biological effects of ozone: 6. Production
of
transforming growth factor P by human blood after ozone
treatment.
i. Biol. Regul. Homeost. Agents (in press)
41 Bocci, V. (1988) Roles of interferon produced in physiological
conditions. A speculative review. Immunology 64, 1-9.
42 Novogrodsky, A., Stenzel, K.I-l. and Rubin, A.L. (1977)
Stimulntioo of human peripheral blood lymphocytes by
periodate,
galactose oxidase, soybean agglutinin, and peanut agglutinin:
differential effects of adherent cells. J. Immunol. 118,
852-857.
43 Dianzani, I;., Monahan, 1`. and Santiano, M. (1981)
Mechanism
of induction of gamma incerfcron.'I'exns Rep. Biol. &
Mcd.
41.')')-1()7.
44 Schrcck, R., Rieber, P. and Uaeuerlc, I'.A. (1991)
Reactive
oxygn intermediates as apparently widely used messengers
ill the
activation of the NF-KU transcription factor anti HIV-l,
EMBO J.
10, 2247-2258.
45 Lenardo, M. and Siebenlist, U. (1994) Bcl-3-mediated
nuclear
regulatiun of the NF-kB trans-activating factor. Immunol.
Today
15, 145-147.
46 13uttke, T.M. and Snndstrom, P.A. (1994) Oxid;rtive
stress ;Is
;I mediator of apoptosis. Immunol. Today 15, 7-10.
47 Aey, D. and Walton, T.E. (1985) Liquid-phase study
of ozone
inactivation of Venezuelan Equine Encephalomyelitis virus.
Appl.
Environ. Microbiol. 50, 882-886.
48 Carpendale. M.T.F. and Freeberg, J.K. (1991) Ozone
inactivates
HIV at oncytotoxic concentrations. Antivir. Res. 16,
281-292.
49 Wells, K.H., Latino, J., Gavalchin, J. and Poiesz,
B.J. (1991)
Inactivation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 by
ozone in
vitro. Blood 78, 1882-1890.
50 Bocci, V. (1994) A reasonable approach for the treatment
of HIV
infection in the early phase with ozonetherapy (autohemotherapy).
How inflammatory cytokines may have a therapeutic role.
Mediat.
Inflamm. 3, 315-321.
51 Washuttl, J., Viebahn, R. and Steiner, 1. (1989) Immunologicnl
examinations in patients with chronic conditions under
adnlinistration of ozone/oxygen mixtures. Ozone Sci.
& Engin.
52 I;ahmy, Z. (1994) immunological effect of ozone (OJO,)in
rheumatic diseases. In: Proceedings "Ozone application
in
Medicine", Thursday, Septerllber 1, 191)4, Zurich, Switzerland.
pp. 62-77.
53 Taga, K., Mostowski, H. and Tosato, G. (1993) Iiurnan
interleukin-lO can tlirectly inhibit T-cell growth. Blood
81.
2964-2971.
54 Brandes, M.E., Alien, J.B., Ogawa, Y. and Wahl, S.M.
(1991)
Transfonning growth factor
pr suppresses acute and chronic arthritis in experimental
animals.
J. Clin. Lnvest. 87,
1108-1113.
55 Kuruvilla, A.P., Shah, R., Hochwald, G.M., Liggitt,
M.D.,
Palladino, M.A. and Thorbecke, G.J. (1991) Protective
effect of
transforming growth factor P, on experimental autoimmune
diseases
in mice. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 2918-2921.
56 Bocci, V. (1981) Determinants of erythrocyte ageing:
a
reappraisal. Brit. J. Haematol. 48, 515-522.
57 Bocci, V., Luzzi, E., Corradeschi, F. and Paulesu,
L. (1994)
Studies on the biological effects of ozone: 5. Evaluation
of
immunological parameters and tolerability in normal volunteers
receiving ambulatory autohaemotherapy. Biotherapy 7,
83-5)0.
58 Mackensen, A., Galanos, C. and Engelhardt, R. (1991)
I'reatment
of cancer patients with endotoxin induces release of
endogenous
cytokines. Pathobiology 59, 264-267.
59 Towbin, H., Schmitz, A., Jakschies, D., von Wussow,
P. and I-
Iorisberger, M.A. (1992) A whole blood immunoassay for
the
interferon-inducible human Mr protein. J. Interferon
lies.
12, 67-74.
60 Bocci, V. (1992) The neglected organ: bacterial flora
has a
crucial immunostimulatory
role. Perspect. Biol. Med. 35, 251-260.
61 Westermann, J. and Pabst, K. (1992) Distribution of
lymphocyte
subsets and natural killer cells in the human body. Clin.
Investig. 70, 539-544.
62 Vitetta, E.S., Thorpe, P.E. and Uhr, J.W. (1993) Immunotoxins:
magic bullets or misguided missiles? Immunol. Today 14,
252-259.
63 Rosenberg, S.A., Lotze, M.T. and Mule, J.J. (1988)
New
approaches to the immunotherapy of cancer using interleukin-2.
Ann. Intent. Med. 108, 853-801.
64 I-Iadden, J.W. (1993) Immunostimulants. Immunol. Today
14, 275-
280.
65 Bocci, V. (1990) Tumor therapy with biological response
modifiers. Why is progress slow? EOS- J. Immunol. Immunopharmacol.
10, 79-82.
66 Cetto, G.L. and Franceschi, T. (1994) E' giustificato
ii costo
econornico del trattamento in funzione dei risultati
possibili?
I;orum 4.1(suppl.l), 38-40.
67 Sporn, M.B. and Roberts, A.B. (1993) A major advance
in the use
of growth factors to enhance wound healing. J. Clin.
Invest. 92,
2565-2566.
68 Takeshita, S., Zheng, L.P., Brogi, E., Kearney, M.,
Pu, L.Q.,
Bunting, S., Ferrara, N., Symes, J.F. and Isner, J.M.
(1994)
Therapeutic angiogenesis. A single intraarterial bolus
of
vascular endothelial growth factor augments revascularization
in a
rabbit ischernic hind limb model. J. Clin. Invest. 93,
662-670.
69 Schmid, P., Cox, D., Bilbe, (;., McMaster, G., Morrison.
C.,
Stahelin, H., L,iischer, N. and Seller, W. (1993) TGF-Ps
and
?`GI;-B type II receptor in human epidcrmis:differential
expression in acute and chronic skin wounds. J. Pathol.
171, 191-
197.
70 Bobik, A. and Campbell, J.H. (1993) Vascular derived
growth
factors: cell biology, pathophysiology, and pharmacology.
Pharmacol. Kev. 45, 1-42.
--------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------